How The Times and Sunday Times build communities through comments
The Times has been around since 1785, and today has nearly 700,000 paid digital subscribers. Like many news publishers, retaining paying subscribers is vital for The Times, Rachel Duffy, Head of Community for The Times & The Sunday Times, told participants at our Newsroom Summit conference.
“How do we make sure that they stay?” Duffy asked. “We needed to make them feel like they are part of a community.”
One key way The Times and Sunday Times is doing this by taking an area already popular with their readers – the comments section – and then doubling down to make the most of it.
The Times gets about 650,000 comments a month, Duffy said, and about 41 percent of their readers regularly read the comments section.
The Times wanted encourage comments from all news and opinions articles, “and to do so in ways that encourage better comments as a result,” she said.
While they are interested in getting more comments, they don’t want growth to come at the expense of quality, she said.
Community needs to go hand-in-hand with quality, she said. “We’ve spent a lot of time designing platforms that measure the quality of our comments, so it’s not just about increasing that volume.”
“Seventy percent of all Times readers live in our app,” Duffy noted. “We’ve spent a lot of time and investment making sure the app is the place to be.”
WAN-IFRA’s Newsroom Summit is bringing together 125+ delegates from 30 countries on five continents. We’re gathered at Verdens Gang (VG), Norway’s leading digital media house, in Oslo for this two-day event. Photo by Tom Atle Bordevik / Bordevik.no.
‘Meet readers where they already are’
The percentage of users who read the comments section is between a third and a half, Duffy noted.
What’s more, 41 percent of their time reading an article is now spent reading the comments section, she said.
Duffy has a team of four. “We moderate the comments, we place conversation starters and polls.”
“We’re just trying to meet readers where they already are,” she added.
As is the case for many other publishers, a relatively small percentage of readers actually write comments, but many readers are interested in reading them.
“So we want it to be a positive place. We don’t want our readers’ first experience of the comments section to be a negative experience, so we’re spending a lot of time moderating in the traditional sense of the word, but we’re also bringing in new voices,” she said.
Getting their journalists involved
How that works in practice is that The Times encourages its writers to go into the Comments section, where the readers already are, to do more of their journalism, Duffy said.
“It wasn’t about building another product, to engage readers or spend a lot of time on marketing to encourage them to go to a new section of the app. They’re already there in the comments section.”
“On a data point, this is brilliant for our dwell time. If you remove the comments section, you can see the impact that would have on dwell time. If you start getting people’s favourite writers into the comments section, you can also see the impact that that will have.”
For example, columnist Matthew Syed is a household name for regular readers of The Sunday Times, Duffy noted. Syed is also a regular contributor to the BBC, and has a large following.
Now, Times subscribers have a direct line to him every Sunday morning between 10 am to 11 am, when Syed spends an hour replying directly to reader comments about why he wrote a column on the subject he did, or the interviews that have stayed with him, Duffy said.
“And that direct line is what our future journalism is all about,” she said.
Mobilising readers attending World Cup matches
Another example is how The Times turned their readers into creators during this year’s World Cup.
In the past, a typical approach would have been to ask readers if they are going to the World Cup. The publisher would then write one separate article “Meet The Times readers going to the World Cup,” which might well end up buried on the homepage, she noted.
“We want our readers at the heart of all of our journalism, so we made a WhatsApp group of our readers,” Duffy said. “They sent live colour before every match, pictures and videos from the stands that we wouldn’t necessarily have had. We’ve got our stock imagery and our brilliant sports writers on the ground, but this colour was amazing for other readers who weren’t there and that their story was the coverage.”
These readers contributed posts celebrating England’s wins, and commiserating after losses. “They were at the heart of our journalism – it wasn’t a one-and-done article,” Duffy noted.
Bringing their comments on stage
The Times’ efforts go beyond digital. Last year, for example, they brought their comments section to life after the major election that led to the resignation of Keir Starmer as the UK’s prime minister.
While many of their competitors used panels of experts, Duffy said The Times decided to literally put their community on centre stage.
They had five Times and Sunday Times readers, each representing the political party that they had voted for in those local elections on stage with Fraser Nelson, a Times columnist and former editor of The Spectator magazine.
“It highlighted that The Times is a broad church of political opinion that the comments section in real life are those same conversations: That people can be articulate and thoughtful and fundamentally disagree,” Duffy said.
Such community-minded initiatives are continuing, Duffy said.
For example, they’ve just launched The Times Money Investment Club. For this, they are focusing on five readers, each representing a different ages and stages of their investment journeys. One is a young man in his 20s, who can invest 50 pounds a month, and wants to start a portfolio, others are more seasoned investors, Duffy said.
“We’ll be following their journey with financial experts advice from our own Money desk, and also mapping it against current affairs and news stories, such as the budget and any announcements from the US and others,” she said.






